California Attorney General Rob Bonta and Secretary of State Shirley N. Weber have filed an appeal to overturn a recent decision by the Orange County Superior Court regarding Huntington Beach's voter identification law, Measure A. The measure, which amends the city's charter to impose voter ID requirements for municipal elections starting in 2026, was deemed "not ripe for adjudication" by the court on November 15, 2024. The court stated that Measure A is "permissive and discretionary in character" and does not currently conflict with state election laws.
Attorney General Bonta criticized the court's decision, stating, "The Orange County Superior Court got it wrong — plain and simple. Secretary of State Weber and I firmly believe not only that the time is right for us to bring our lawsuit but also that Huntington Beach’s voter ID policy is unlawful." He announced plans to file a brief with the California Fourth District Court of Appeal outlining why they believe the trial court erred.
Secretary of State Weber emphasized her role in ensuring compliance with state election laws. She said, "As California’s chief elections officer, I am responsible for the administration and enforcement of the state’s election laws. Part of that role is ensuring that we encourage democracy through voter participation and stop attempts that burden democracy by preventing or discouraging eligible citizens from voting."
The state's lawsuit against Measure A was filed on April 15, 2024. It argues that Measure A conflicts with state law as local ordinances cannot override matters of statewide concern like electoral integrity and voters' rights. According to the lawsuit, California already has a comprehensive legal framework to protect these interests.
A copy of the notice of appeal is available online.