Legal Newsline

Wednesday, February 26, 2020

Ala. governor signs bill reversing state SC’s ‘innovator liability’ ruling

By Jessica M. Karmasek | May 4, 2015

Bentleysigningsb80 300x185

MONTGOMERY, Ala. (Legal Newsline) - Alabama Gov. Robert Bentley has signed into law a bill overturning a state Supreme Court ruling that held a brand-name drug manufacturer can be liable for physical injuries caused by a generic drug product that it neither made nor sold.


The measure, Senate Bill 80, garnered bipartisan support in the state legislature. The Senate passed the bill 32-9 last month and the House previously voted 88-7 to pass its version, House Bill 110. The Senate version was sponsored by Sen. Cam Ward, a Republican. The House bill was sponsored by Rep. Jack “J.D.” Williams, also a Republican.


Last week, the House voted 86-14 on final passage of SB 80 and sent it to Bentley, a Republican, for consideration.

Bentley signed the measure Friday.


“Today I signed SB 80,” the governor said in a series of Twitter posts. “It’s an important bill for our pro-business state and it will help recruit businesses to Alabama.


“I appreciate Sen. Ward and Rep. Williams for working on the bill to protect Alabama businesses from this type of litigation.


“Companies should be held liable for injuries caused by a product that was made by a different company.”


Lawmakers crafted the bill after the Alabama Supreme Court issued its ruling in Weeks v. Wyeth in 2013 and then reheard the case and reaffirmed its ruling last year.


“In the context of inadequate warnings by the brand-name manufacturer placed on a prescription drug manufactured by a generic manufacturer, it is not fundamentally unfair to hold the brand-name manufacturer liable for warnings on a product it did not produce because the manufacturing process is irrelevant to misrepresentation theories based, not on manufacturing defects in the product itself, but on information and warning deficiencies, when those alleged misrepresentations were drafted by the brand-name manufacturer and merely repeated, as allowed by the (Food and Drug Administration), by the generic manufacturer,” Justice Michael Bolin wrote in the majority opinion last year.


Plaintiffs Danny and Vicki Weeks sued five current and former drug manufacturers for injuries that Danny Weeks allegedly suffered as a result of his long term use of prescription drug Reglan, which is used to treat gastric esophageal reflux disease, or GERD.


In its initial January 2013 ruling, the high court answered in the affirmative the question of whether a brand-name drug manufacturer, based on statements made in connection with the manufacture or distribution of the brand-name drug, may be liable to a plaintiff who has claimed injury from a generic version of the brand-name drug.


A month later, Pfizer, along with Wyeth LLC and Schwarz Pharma Inc., petitioned for rehearing and asked the court to reject “innovator liability.”


The majority said its decision to reaffirm does not turn products-liability law, or tort law, “on its head.”


“Nor are we creating a new tort of ‘innovator liability,’ as has been suggested,” Bolin wrote of the manufacturers’ arguments.


“Instead, we are answering a question of law involving a product that, unlike any other product on the market, has unprecedented federal regulation.”


Bolin continued, “Nothing in this opinion suggests that a plaintiff can sue Black & Decker for injuries caused by a power tool manufactured by Skil based on labeling or otherwise.”


But business groups feared the ramifications of the court’s decision would be felt in other industries in the state and across the country.


The Business Council of Alabama -- one of the entities that filed an amicus brief in the case -- praised lawmakers for taking action and Bentley for moving quickly to sign the bill into law.


“Had this correction not been swiftly made, Alabama would have been at a great disadvantage in attracting new business investment, which is key to bringing economic growth and jobs to our state,” BCA President and CEO William J. Canary said in a statement Friday.


According to its website, BCA is the state’s exclusive affiliate to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the National Association of Manufacturers.


The Chamber’s Institute for Legal Reform owns Legal Newsline.


From Legal Newsline: Reach Jessica Karmasek by email at

Want to get notified whenever we write about any of these organizations ?

Sign-up Next time we write about any of these organizations, we'll email you a link to the story. You may edit your settings or unsubscribe at any time.

Organizations in this Story

National Association of ManufacturersAlabama Supreme Court