Legal Newsline

Sunday, January 26, 2020

GOP state senator to run for Pa. AG

By Jessica Karmasek | Jun 19, 2015


HARRISBURG, Pa. (Legal Newsline) - Republican state Sen. John Rafferty has decided to run for Pennsylvania attorney general.

Rafferty made his announcement Wednesday, according to the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review.

Current Attorney General Kathleen Kane, the first woman and Democrat elected attorney general, has said she will seek re-election.

Rafferty, a former state deputy attorney general, was re-elected to a fourth term in the Senate in November 2014. He represents residents in the state’s 44th District, which includes parts of Berks, Chester and Montgomery counties.

He currently serves as chairman of the Senate Transportation Committee, vice chairman of the Judiciary Committee, and is a member of Appropriations, Consumer Protection and Professional Licensure, and Law and Justice committees.

Prior to his time in the Senate, Rafferty served as an attorney in private practice, focusing on education, real estate, zoning and business, and estates law.

As deputy attorney general for the state from 1988 to 1991, he worked in the Criminal Law Division.

He earned his undergraduate degree from the University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown, his master’s degree from Beaver College, and his law degree from Temple University.

“Unfortunately, there’s been a black cloud over the attorney general’s office of late,” Rafferty said Wednesday, according to the Tribune-Review. “Resources have been committed to addressing other issues that have arisen in that office.

“I want to bring integrity back to that office. I want to bring responsibility back to that office.”

Kane, in her short time in office, has been mired in legal problems.

Among her troubles: her relationship with plaintiffs law firm Cohen Milstein Sellers & Toll.

Since 2010, Cohen Milstein has donated $71,000 to 16 different campaigns, according to a search of Of those candidates, 13 would go on to win their state’s general election.

Some of the firm’s largest donations went to: Missouri Attorney General Chris Koster, $5,000; Oregon Attorney General Ellen Rosenblum, $10,000; New Mexico Attorney General Hector Balderas, $5,000; and Kane, $10,000.

Cohen Milstein’s relationship with Kane came to the forefront in April when a group of nursing home operators filed a lawsuit in Pennsylvania’s Commonwealth Court trying to kill the firm’s apparent deal with the Attorney General’s Office.

The dozens of owners and operators of long-term care facilities in the state, which filed their petition for review April 2, argue that the attorney general has overstepped her bounds in investigating skilled nursing facilities’ staffing levels and hiring Cohen Milstein to help conduct the investigation.

“The General Assembly has not granted OAG the jurisdiction to investigate SNF staffing levels, nor has it delegated to OAG the authority to litigate against SNFs based on OAG’s assessment of the sufficiency of nursing staff. Rather, the General Assembly has authorized (the Pennsylvania Department of Health) to exercise exclusive jurisdiction over the investigation, monitoring and enforcement of regulations against SNFs,” the operators wrote in their 46-page petition.

“The OAG’s issuance of the subpoenas, its investigation of the sufficiency of nurse staffing levels at Petitioners’ SNFs and its pursuit of litigation against Petitioners is improper and in derogation of the exclusive authority of PA DOH. As such, the Subpoenas are invalid, and Respondents Kane, OAG and Cohen Milstein should not be allowed to continue this unlawful investigation of nursing staff levels at Petitioners’ SNFs.”

The operators -- certified providers under federal Medicare and Medicaid programs, with at least 10,995 licensed beds in the state -- contend the subpoenas seek information strictly for purposes of litigation.

“Given the terms of the contingent fee agreement between Cohen Milstein and OAG, including the financial arrangements and incentives contained therein, as well as Cohen Milstein’s and OAG’s conduct in these investigations thus far, discussed in detail below, it is evident that litigation against petitioners is intended, imminent and inevitable,” they wrote.

The operators also argue that Kane’s delegation of authority to the law firm is improper because it gives the firm a financial stake in pursuing litigation against them.

“Cohen Milstein seeks to enrich itself through large contingent fees based on litigation claims made against petitioners in the name of OAG,” they wrote.

“The investigation by Respondent Kane, OAG and Cohen Milstein was not prompted by any material consumer complaints to OAG for allegedly insufficient care, but rather was initiated by Cohen Milstein to extract legal fee recoveries, as reported in the New York Times and other sources.”

The operators continued, “This Cohen Milstein-driven investigation is an effort to create a ‘problem’ where none exists in a search for profits for itself.”

Jeffrey Johnson, assistant press secretary for Kane’s office, told Legal Newsline that the attorney general received the petition, was reviewing it and “will act accordingly.”

Kane’s potential Democratic challengers are former state Rep. and Montgomery County Commissioner Josh Shapiro and Philadelphia District Attorney Seth Williams.

State Rep. Todd Stephens reportedly also is considering a run in the GOP primary.

The state’s primaries tentatively are set for April 26, 2016. The general election will be held Nov. 8, 2016.

From Legal Newsline: Reach Jessica Karmasek by email at

Want to get notified whenever we write about ?

Sign-up Next time we write about , we'll email you a link to the story. You may edit your settings or unsubscribe at any time.