Legal Newsline

Monday, March 30, 2020

Jindal files appeal in case over La. SC's next chief justice

By Jessica M. Karmasek | Sep 10, 2012



NEW ORLEANS (Legal Newsline) - Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal is now getting involved in the fight over who will become the state Supreme Court's next chief justice.

Jindal, a Republican, filed a two-page notice of appeal in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana late Friday.

The governor's filing comes just two days after Judge Susie Morgan entered a judgment in favor of Justice Bernette Johnson.

The federal judge ruled that Johnson is entitled to become the high court's next chief justice based on her seniority.

In her lawsuit filed in July, Johnson requested that the federal court enforce its consent judgment in Chisom v. Roemer.

Johnson, who was elected as the Chisom judge in 1994 and was reelected as a permanent justice in 2000 and 2010, argued in the suit she is next in line for the job of chief justice.

Meanwhile, fellow Justice Jeffrey Victory argued he has the right to succeed Chief Justice Catherine "Kitty" Kimball, who announced in April that she is retiring from the Court in January 2013.

Victory, who joined the Court a year after Johnson, argued that he is senior to Johnson because her years as a Chisom judge do not count toward her seniority.

Under Louisiana law, the chief justice position shall be filled by the longest-serving justice on the Court.

"The court finds that the interpretation of the consent judgment is within its inherent jurisdiction," Morgan wrote in her full 50-page ruling, filed Sept. 1.

"The court finds that the consent judgment provides for Justice Johnson's service on the Louisiana Supreme Court from Nov. 16, 1994 to Oct. 7, 2000 to be credited to her tenure on the court for all purposes under Louisiana law."

The judge continued, "As the Supreme Court held in Perschall v. State, the State, including the Supreme Court as an arm of the State, is bound by the terms of the consent judgment."

Former Louisiana Attorney General Richard P. Ieyoub argued in support of Johnson in a case filing last month.

Ieyoub, who currently practices with Baton Rouge firm Hymel, Davis and Peterson, served as the state's top lawyer from 1992 to 2004.

When he assumed office in 1992, the litigation at issue -- Chisom -- was ongoing.

Soon after, Ieyoub began the process of trying to reach a settlement in the matter.

He explained in his two-page declaration that an "essential" part of that settlement was the creation of an eighth justice of the state Supreme Court to be elected from Orleans Parish.

"This part of the settlement was crucial because it gave immediate relief to the Orleans Parish African-American voters whose voting strength was being diluted," he wrote.

"This eighth justice seat (commonly referred to as the Chisom seat) gave this underrepresented group an immediate presence on the Supreme Court until the Supreme Court districts could be redrawn at a later time."

The city of New Orleans also backed Johnson.

In an amicus brief filed in the case, the city asked that the federal court recognize the justice's tenure as a Chisom judge and count it as years of service on the state's high court in an effort to "protect the citizens of this parish and city and to prevent the dilution of their voting strength."

"If Justice Bernette Joshua Johnson's Chisom service is not counted towards her point of service pursuant to Louisiana Constitution Article V, Section 6 to permit her to succeed as the next chief justice, then Justice Johnson's participation on the Louisiana Supreme Court pursuant to the consent judgment would not have been 'equal' during this period of assignment," it wrote in its three-page brief.

"This is what is due our citizens, and this is what the terms of the consent judgment mandate."

According to Jindal's filing Friday, the governor will appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.

Representing him in the matter are Kevin R. Tully, E. Phelps Gay, Elizabeth S. Cordes and H. Carter Marshall of the New Orleans law firm of Christovich and Kearney LLP.

Jindal had stayed out of the proceeding up until last week, saying it was a matter for the courts to decide.

However, he now believes it is an issue for the State, and not the federal court, to decide, according to The Times-Picayune.

From Legal Newsline: Reach Jessica Karmasek by email at

Want to get notified whenever we write about Louisiana Supreme Court ?

Sign-up Next time we write about Louisiana Supreme Court, we'll email you a link to the story. You may edit your settings or unsubscribe at any time.

Organizations in this Story

Louisiana Supreme Court