State Farm calls AG Hood's spin on settlement 'perplexing'

John O'Brien Aug. 6, 2008, 4:26pm


JACKSON, Miss. (Legal Newsline) - Mississippi Attorney General Jim Hood says his lawsuit against State Farm Insurance made the company pay $74 million it initially refused to give to policyholders affected by 2005's Hurricane Katrina.

State Farm didn't exactly agree Wednesday, responding to a press conference during which Hood announced he was dropping the lawsuit he filed against the company after Katrina.

Much has happened since then, including a federal judge rejecting a Jan. 2007 settlement reached by the two sides, a breach of contract suit by Hood, a major war of words between the two and State Farm establishing a claims revisiting process with the state's Insurance Department.

"We find it perplexing Attorney General Hood is taking full credit for the resolution process he opposed and was the basis for his lawsuit against State Farm which he has now settled," State Farm said in a statement.

"Nonetheless, we are pleased the Attorney General understands State Farm has met its obligations under the agreement made with his office in Jan. 2007. State Farm has been focused on resolving all pending matters related to Katrina and this is another step toward resolution."

Hood alleged in June 2007 a bad faith breach of contract on State Farm's part for refusing to reconstruct the rejected January settlement.

In the aftermath of Katrina, Hood said five insurance companies wrongfully represented the amount of water damage to some homes because flood damage, covered by the National Flood Insurance Program, is excluded from their policies.

The two sides appeared to have settled in Jan. 2007 when State Farm agreed to terms that could have cost them between $50 million-$500 million, Hood estimated.

However, U.S. District Judge L.T. Senter rejected parts of the settlement because he worried about the amount of control State Farm would possess during an arbitration process that started when a policyholder rejected the company's initial claim -- an automatic 50 percent of the structural value of the property according to the policy.

Because State Farm did not fix the rejected settlement to conform to the federal court's guidelines, Hood says the company breached its contract with the state.

State Farm, meanwhile, began revisiting claims as part of a deal reached with Insurance Commissioner George Dale. That deal, State Farm said, mirrored the one originally reached with Hood.

It is through that process that State Farm has paid $74 million to policyholders.

"The key to (the rejected settlement) was both sides used arbiters, and we estimated at that time that coastal policyholders, as a result of the arbitration with fair and impartial arbiters being involved, would have been paid in the neighborhood of $476 million, but that did not occur," Hood said.

"We found they agreed to pay the $50 million minimum and they have paid that, so we settled that with them."

Hood said only 148 "slab" and "pier" cases remain. Those cases involve near or total destruction of a building. State Farm must send notices to those 148 policyholders to ask them to be a part of the claims revisiting process.

Hood added that without his lawsuit, State Farm would have completely stiffed coastal policyholders who suffered the worst of the storm.

"It's been a difficult task, I'm sure, for them as a company to try to handle these massive claims," Hood said.

"What they did wrong is they zeroed people out. Over 1,000 people had slab and pier cases and they told them, 'You get zero.'

"What we've been able to do is make them pay an additional $74 million."

Hood also had a criminal investigation into State Farm's practices. The company felt Hood used it to force a settlement of his civil suit.

From Legal Newsline: Reach John O'Brien by e-mail at

Want to get notified whenever we write about Mississippi Attorney General ?
Next time we write about Mississippi Attorney General, we'll email you a link to the story. You may edit your settings or unsubscribe at any time.

Organizations in this Story

Mississippi Attorney General
550 High St Suite 1200
Jackson, MS 39201

More News